Disorder and instability are matters of continuing public concern. Terrorism, as a threat to global order, has been added to preoccupations with political unrest, deviance and crime. Such considerations have prompted the return to the classic anthropological issues of order and disorder. Examining order within the political and legal spheres and in contrasting local settings, the papers in this volume highlight its complex and contested nature. Elaborate displays of order seem necessary to legitimate the institutionalization of violence by military and legal establishments, yet violent behaviour can be incorporated into the social order by the development of boundaries, rituals and established processes of conflict resolution. Order is said to depend upon justice, yet injustice legitimates disruptive protest. Case studies from Siberia, India, Indonesia, Tibet, West Africa, Morocco and the Ottoman Empire show that local responses are often inconsistent in their valorization, acceptance and condemnation of disorder.
Order and Disorder: Anthropological Perspectives, edited by esteemed anthropologists Keebet von Benda-Beckmann and Fernanda Pirie, offers a compelling exploration of the complex and often contradictory relationship between societal order and disorder. Published by Berghahn Books in 2011, this thought-provoking volume delves into the enduring human preoccupation with stability, security, and the ever-present threat of chaos. In a world grappling with terrorism, political unrest, and a general sense of unease, this book provides vital insights into how different societies construct, maintain, and challenge the boundaries of acceptable behavior. Von Benda-Beckmann, a renowned legal anthropologist known for her work on plural legal systems and conflict resolution, and Pirie, an expert in the anthropology of law and governance, bring together a diverse collection of essays that examine order and disorder through a variety of lenses. This is not a simplistic dichotomy, but rather a nuanced understanding of how the concepts are intertwined, contested, and constantly renegotiated within specific cultural contexts. Moving beyond theoretical debates, "Order and Disorder" presents rich ethnographic case studies from across the globe, including Siberia, India, Indonesia, Tibet, West Africa, Morocco, and even historical examples from the Ottoman Empire. These studies reveal that local responses to disorder are far from uniform. They highlight the inconsistencies in how societies valorize, accept, and condemn disruptive behaviors, demonstrating the deeply embedded cultural values that shape these reactions. The book challenges conventional assumptions about the foundations of social order. For example, it examines how elaborate displays of order are often crucial for legitimizing the use of violence by military and legal institutions. Paradoxically, violent behavior itself can be integrated into the social fabric through the development of boundaries, rituals, and established processes of conflict resolution. The authors demonstrate how the very concept of "justice," often seen as a cornerstone of order, can also be a catalyst for disruptive protest when perceived as unfair or unequally applied. "Order and Disorder" is not simply an academic exercise. It provides valuable perspectives for policymakers, legal professionals, and anyone interested in understanding the dynamics of social change and conflict resolution. By highlighting the complex interplay between order and disorder in diverse cultural settings, this book offers a critical lens for analyzing contemporary social and political challenges. It encourages readers to move beyond simplistic notions of stability and chaos and to appreciate the nuanced ways in which societies navigate the ever-present tension between these two fundamental forces. A crucial resource for students and scholars in political anthropology, social conflict, and political violence, this book is a vital contribution to understanding the human condition. This first edition paperback comprises 184 pages of insightful analysis and thought-provoking research. With an ISBN-13 of 9780857451484, this English-language book weighs 259 grams.